Undermining Your Good Point With A Really Dumb One

From PerthNow: West Coast name is 'dumb'

FOOTBALL commentator Dennis Cometti says the name of the 2006 AFL football champions, the West Coast Eagles, is "American crapola".

Cometti says that West Coast Eagles is a "dumb name'' and that the side should have been called the Perth Eagles.

I couldn't agree more. I've always hated regional appellations. I can't stand the "Texas" Rangers, or the "Golden State" Warriors. Teams should be named after the areas they are actually representing...like the Dallas Rangers, or the Minneapolis Twins, or the stinking, rat infested swamps of Jersey Devils.

Of course, the guy makes a good point and then has to flush said point right down the old toilet:

He said it was a travesty that no AFL side was named Perth, robbing the state of international exposure.

He said that at a time when WA's reputation was suffering nationally and internationally because of image and corruption problems, the state could have benefited by telling the world it had the nation's best football side.

International exposure? For Aussie rules? I hate to break it him, but the as for the extent of international exposure...if you are reading this that will pretty much be the extent of it. I don't think calling the team Perth Eagles would do all that much. It isn't as if everyone here in the states goes on and on about the Swans or something.

Cometti claimed that "privately'', the West Coast Eagles had acknowledged there was a problem with the club's name and had canvassed the idea of a change - claims strenuously denied by West Coast Eagles chief executive Trevor Nisbett.

He said yesterday that during his 18 years at the club, the Eagles had never discussed changing the name to Perth Eagles, or anything else, and he could not see that happening in the future.

"People who set up the club gave an enormous amount of thought to the name,'' he said.

"It encapsulates the whole of the state, from Esperance through to Wyndham. The club is for all West Australians, not just people from Perth.''

Mr Nisbett disagreed with Cometti's view that Perth Eagles would help sell the city and the state.

"Most people (overseas) don't even know where Perth is, let along the West Coast, so I don't know that it particularly makes any difference,'' he said.

Cometti, widely regarded as Australia's best football commentator, said Perth needed a bit more excitement.

"Generally, if you are looking for excitement in Perth, you are barking up the wrong tree,'' he said.

I know I'm just a dumb American, but I'd guess that the West Coast Eagles are located somewhere on Australia's West Coast.

But that is me...always going out on a limb.

Comments

Early Thoughts on City 2025

There are few things harder to keep track of than an MLS side in their off-season, at least for me. Despite the fact it takes place roughly during the time the MLB Hot Stove season is in full swing, it is nowhere near as easy to follow along with as baseball. Part of it is how disconnected MLS is with the international soccer calendar. St. Louis City SC is still digesting the moves it made last summer even though those players have already played important games for the club. It is all weird and disjointed, and I always feel like I am playing catch-up. Happily, the moves made in the off-season this year were not numerous. German Timo Baumgartl comes over from Europe as an option at center back, which is good because that was a position that was a little rocky for City last season. Given his own troubles over the last few seasons (cancer and uneven play in the aftermath of that), a spell with City can give Baumgartl a chance to have a re-set. Given his pedigree and the fact City si...

Blues Fall Off a Cliff

Hockey seasons will have their ups and downs. For whatever reason, be it injuries, a challenging schedule, an inexplicable loss of form, it is difficult for teams to maintain a good level of compete for an entire season. The good teams just limit their funks. The St. Louis Blues, however, are not a good team. They are a poor team, and poor teams sink under the weight of "here we go again" night after night. I will admit I only watched the first two periods of last night's 5-0 loss to a Colorado team that had been scuffling of late. Two periods were more than enough to get the gist of it. It was also enough to lead me to a diagnosis as to what ails the team. It isn't that they are young and are going through growing pains. No, the reason the Blues are so bad is that the veterans who are being paid to be the backbone of this team are not doing their jobs. I'm talking about Schenn, Buchnevich, Faulk, and even Binnington and Parayko. Over $30M of the salary cap is b...

A Note of Optimism About the Note

If you have been trying to watch the St. Louis Blues attempt to play hockey of late it would be hard to believe the word optimism could ever be in play. The losses continue relentlessly, often in the "never in the game" style, but increasingly in a "lose from winning position" flair which is enough to make someone turn on the news for an upbeat change of pace. (Wow, plane crashes and LUNACY!) This team still can't score with the regularity needed to win consistently in this league. The coaching staff knows they have precious few natural goal scorers (one is precious few), so they attempt to make up for it by getting what I call "process" goals, i.e. goals scored by virtue of constant pressure, crazy bounces, accidental deflections, etc. Basically, any goal you can get from a player who doesn't have the knack for scoring them on their own. The Blues are something like zero for their last 12-15 breakaway chances, and zero for their last 25-30 2 on 1...

(Get) A Sporting Life

Search This Blog